215 Program: Section of Anti-terror Patriot Act That Authorizes the NSA to Collect Americans' Phone Records
June 20, 2013
AP - Seeking to win over public trust, the Obama administration has been
throwing around a lot of numbers as it tries to describe — in as much
detail as possible without jeopardizing national security — the terror
plots it says were thwarted by the government's sweeping
surveillance of U.S. communications.
There's 50, 12, 10 and four. You also hear 20 and 90 in statements
and official testimony, and even 702 and 215, though those aren't for
estimates of plots.
The numbers game is just part of the effort to convince skeptical Americans that the recently disclosed
National Security Agency
spy programs are vital in detecting and stopping extremist plots. But
the approach has produced relatively limited, often vague information,
and it has ended up confusing many in Congress as lawmakers grapple with
how to assure people that their privacy rights are protected along with
their security.
There are questions about effectiveness that still lack answers, "and we've gotten some answers that need further clarity,"
House Intelligence Committee member Rep.
Adam Schiff,
D-Calif., said Thursday. He was referring to the so-called 215 program,
which refers to the section of the anti-terror Patriot Act that
authorizes the NSA to collect Americans'
phone records.
And, he added, "we also should ask in those cases where it was successful, how dated were the records."
Another NSA program — known as 702 — authorizes the agency to sweep up
Internet usage data from all over the world that goes through nine major U.S.-based providers.
Officials have used the rest of the numbers in Capitol Hill testimony
over the past week as they have sought to allay Americans' concerns
that the programs violate their privacy.
Top officials told Congress that the programs have been key in
thwarting at least 50 terror plots across 20 countries. And, they said,
an estimated 10 to 12 of those plots were directed at the U.S. They
publicly offered four examples among the 50-plus cases:
—An NSA-provided phone record led authorities to identify a terrorist financier in San Diego who was arrested in 2007.
—The NSA's surveillance of Internet usage in 2009 revealed that a Chicago man,
David Headley,
was plotting to bomb a Danish newspaper that had published a cartoon of
the prophet Muhammad, Deputy FBI Director Sean Joyce said. The FBI had
been tipped off that Headley was involved in the deadly 2008 Mumbai
terror attacks.
—Information from the NSA's
Internet usage surveillance of overseas operatives helped thwart a 2009
plot to blow up the New York City subway system. NSA Director General
Keith Alexander said this information led investigators to
Najibullah Zazi
in Colorado. And the phone records collection gave investigators the
connections between Zazi and his associates. Zazi ultimately pleaded
guilty and provided information that helped send two of his friends to
prison.
—A plot to blow up the New York Stock Exchange was thwarted in its
early planning stages because the NSA was able identify an extremist in
Yemen who was in touch with Khalid Ouazzani in Kansas City, Mo., Joyce
said. This enabled investigators to identify co-conspirators and prevent
the attack he said. Ouazzani pleaded guilty in May 2010 in federal
court in Missouri to charges of conspiracy to provide material support
to a terrorist organization, bank fraud and money laundering. Ouazzani
was not charged with the alleged plot against the stock exchange.
The administration has yet to provide firm numbers of precisely how
many plots have been stopped worldwide because of these programs — in
part because intelligence officials are still trying to figure that out.
"The reason I'm not giving you a specific number is we want the rest
of the community to actually beat those up and make sure that everything
we have there is exactly right," Alexander said Tuesday during a House
intelligence committee hearing.
"I'd give you the number 50-X, but if
somebody says, 'Well, not this one. Actually, what we're finding out is
there's more. They said you missed these three or four.'"
Alexander said,
"These programs are immensely valuable for protecting
our nation and securing the security of our allies."
And the NSA's
authorization to sweep up Internet usage data has contributed to 90
percent of the information used to thwart at least 50 terror plots
Alexander and his deputy told lawmakers.
On Wednesday, outgoing FBI Director Robert Mueller told the Senate
Judiciary Committee that there are 10 to 12 cases in which the phone
records surveillance program, authorized in the Patriot Act, contributed
to breaking up terror plots.
He said that "of those, domestically, I think there will be anywhere
from 10 or 12 where 215 was important in some way, shape or form."
But later in the same hearing, Mueller said he's not actually sure if
it was the phone records authorization that helped thwart terror
attacks in the 10 to 12 cases.
"I'm not sure whether all of them are 215. They're a combination or
the other," Mueller said, referring to the phone records program and
Internet usage programs.
FBI spokesman Paul Bresson referred requests for clarification to the
NSA and National Counterterrorism Center. He said Mueller "was
obviously unclear on the breakdown" since the FBI is not compiling the
list of cases.
The confusion has, predictably, given rise to demands for more transparency by the intelligence agencies.
A growing number of Democratic and Republican lawmakers are pushing plans to open secret court orders authorizing the surveillance.
Schiff, who filed House legislation on Thursday to match a similar
Senate proposal, said it aimed at "allowing Americans to know how the
court has interpreted the legal authorities" to ensure they are not
being overly or improperly intrusive.
Additionally, a group of mostly Democratic senators are seeking to
amend the Patriot Act to require the government to cite specific
suspected links to terrorism or espionage before asking the secretive
Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court to approve the collection of
Americans' phone records.
But the legislation isn't likely to be approved quickly, and confusion continues to hang over Congress and its constituents.
Noting frustration, Republican House Intelligence Committee Chairman
Mike Rogers said trying to balance support for classified intelligence
programs against a transparent democracy is always a challenge. But all
concerned agree the current situation has fueled public skepticism.
"The public trusts their government to protect the country from
another 9/11-type attack," Rogers said this week, "but that trust can
start to wane when they are faced with inaccuracies, half-truths and
outright lies about the way the intelligence programs are being run."