European Union Creates a Single Overseer under the European Central Bank to Directly Supervise about 150 of the Bloc’s Biggest Banks
July 9, 2013
New York Times - European Union officials are expected on Wednesday to unveil a
detailed plan for dealing with failing banks, which will include
centralized decision making and an emergency fund.
But Germany’s skepticism about giving authority to a group overseen by
the European Commission, as well as other concerns, could bog the
proposal down in months of rancorous negotiations.
On Wednesday, Michel Barnier, the commissioner overseeing financial
services, is expected to call for consolidating decisions under a group
supported by around 300 staff members and creating a pool of money
funded by mandatory levies on banks. The system, which was described
ahead of the formal announcement, would rely on the European Central
Bank to signal when a financial institution in the euro area was facing
severe difficulties.
A resolution board to be made up of representatives from the central
bank, the European Commission and member states of the union would then
make a recommendation, as necessary, on how to shut down or shrink a
bank. The commission, the union’s policy-making arm in Brussels, would
reserve the right to make a final decision.
The board also could draw on the shared fund to help shut down or
radically restructure failing lenders after creditors and shareholders
have borne some losses. European Union officials want the size of the
fund to be as much as 70 billion euros when it is fully funded by 2025.
Giving the commission the power to close banks “is arguably the greatest
transfer of sovereignty in the history of the E.U. and points toward a
fiscal, as well as economic and monetary, union,” said Alexandria Carr, a
lawyer with the firm Mayer Brown in London.
But on Tuesday, Wolfgang Schäuble, the German finance minister, told the
European Commission “to be very careful” with its proposal for a single
authority because “otherwise, we will risk major turbulence.”
“We have to stick to the legal basis we have. Otherwise, we will fail
and we will create new uncertainty in markets,” Mr. Schäuble said to
other European finance ministers as they held their monthly meeting.
Mr. Schäuble insisted, as he has before, that treaties governing the
European Union need to be changed before the plan to centralize decision
making for failing banks — the so-called Single Resolution Mechanism —
goes fully into force. Because treaty changes would be laborious and far
from certain, Mr. Schäuble is arguing for a potentially long delay to
the banking effort.
But France called for swift adoption of the plan.
“We clearly want an agreement,” said the French finance minister, Pierre
Moscovici. That agreement should be reached “by the end of the year,”
he said.
Even as Germany sought to apply the brakes on a broad banking
initiative, European Union finance ministers on Tuesday gave Latvia the
formal go-ahead to use euro notes and coins in January 2014 by setting
the conversion rate at 0.70 lats to 1 euro.
“We trust in Europe and we trust the euro,” Latvia’s finance minister, Andris Vilks, told a news conference.
That celebratory language contrasts with the hesitancy shown by Germany
toward new banking efforts that many experts say are vital to ensuring
the long-term survival of the euro.
After months of wrangling, the European Union decided late last year to
create a single overseer under the European Central Bank that would
directly supervise about 150 of the bloc’s biggest banks. The purpose of
the Single Resolution Mechanism — and the rule book for dealing with
troubled banks that was negotiated two weeks ago — is to prevent the
costs of bank collapses from affecting taxpayers and states.
Such crises can quickly descend into a government debt crisis, as
happened in Spain and in Ireland. Bank failures can also threaten the
stability of the euro area when states can no longer afford the sky-high
government borrowing costs that often come with bailing out their
banks.
The plan for the Single Resolution Mechanism, as well as the proposal
for the single rule book, would still need the approval the European
Parliament.